On Sunday, Critical Role performed a show in Edinburgh for the first time, and I had the privilege to be in the audience. But before going any further, it’s worth explaining what Critical Role is, because this is a writing blog rather than a Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) fansite.
This event is a long‑running collaborative storytelling series where a group of professional voice actors play D&D. They building character arcs, improvise plot turns and twists, and shape an evolving fantasy narrative. It’s part-game and part-performance, combining into a sprawling epic.
I’d known for more than a year that this was happening, but I didn’t instantly snap up a ticket, reasoning that while I did enjoy them, I wasn’t a superfan. That was until earlier this month, when I heard there were a number of resale tickets available. I gave it some consideration. Some pals said I could stay overnight after the event, which eased the logistics enormously, so my mind was made up.
After some fish and chips, we headed to Edinburgh Castle, a location that almost seems engineered for fantasy storytelling. You can bet the audience leaned into it too, with the vast majority of attendees in some form of costume, many head-to-toe.
Their live shows are known for being lengthy, as you can see from the running times of their existing videos. This one ran from 6pm sharp to around 10:40pm, including a 20‑minute break.
I knew the comedian Daniel Sloss would be acting as MC, but I didn’t realise he would play such an integral part in the story. For me, he was an absolute highlight, merging the established tropes with peculiarly Scottish humour. At one point, he offered the actors bottles of Buckfast and they seamlessly made it a minor plot point.
The only downside was the almost absent crowd management. The queues for bathrooms, drinks and merchandise were so unclear that more than on logjam formed without stewards keeping the flow moving. It didn’t derail the actual event, but it was noticeable enough to tar the experience.
I’m giving away as little as possible here because the recording will be available on YouTube in due course. I was quite far away from the action, so I did watch most of it on the giant video screen anyway. It’s different, however, when you’re surrounded by hundreds of people echoing the catchphrases or stamping their feet when the baddies were blasted to bits.
It’s unlikely I’ll be following Critical Role around the world, but if they chose to come back to Scotland in a year or two, I’d consider going again.