The Day of the Gasman

I promise this entry is related to writing. Firstly, however, I need to tell you about how two engineers turned up to carry out a boiler service yesterday, all because of an astonishing coincidence.

Every year, my gas boiler is serviced by a local plumbing company, and the appointment was set for 16 November 2026 between 10:00am and 12:00pm. I was working from home, so when a van turned into my driveway at around 10:45am and an engineer stepped out wearing a Worcester Bosch sweater, I showed him to the cupboard. As he didn’t need anything further, I returned to work.

Around half-an-hour later, the job was complete. I gave an electronic signature on his phone and awaited the safety certificate, which I expected to arrive by email.

Then ten minutes later, another engineer arrived, also wearing a Worcester Bosch sweater and also there to service my boiler. I told him it had just been done, and I provided a description of the first engineer. He said he would look into it and drove away.

Shortly afterwards, I received a phone call from the company I’d booked. We quickly established that whoever had actually serviced my boiler wasn’t connected with them.

I can look back and question why that first engineer arrived in a grey van when I’d been expecting a red one, but some companies subcontract their work, so that didn’t strike me as unusual. However, I didn’t have a certificate or a receipt to show who had done the work.

Later that morning, however, the grey van returned and the mystery was solved. Every so often, a delivery driver will turn up at my address instead of a house in a neighbouring street because the adjoining street names are subtly different.

It turns out the occupants of that house had booked a boiler service with a different company at almost exactly the same time, and none of us had realised until the neighbours rang him to complain.

The engineer was remarkably good about the whole thing. I offered to pay for the service, but he waived the charge and sent me the certificate anyway.

The reason I’m telling you is because writers are often warned to be careful with coincidence. If it’s used too often in fiction, it can feel contrived, even if real-life occasionally hands us a sequence of events that would seem implausible in a novel.

However, I have seen it done well. A prime example appears in the Frederick Forsyth novel The Day of the Jackal.

The French authorities are making little progress investigating a series of armed robberies. During the questioning of a suspect arrested on an unrelated matter, a officer jokingly asks whether he knows anything about the robberies. To his surprise, the suspect begins talking and gives them detailed information about a plot to assassinate Charles de Gaulle, which leads into the events in the rest of the book.

On paper, it sounds terribly convenient, but it works because Forsyth gives the coincidence a believable foundation. The suspect feels he has nothing left to lose and probably saw an opportunity for an early release by giving the authorities something bigger than his own crimes.

It helps enormously that readers are allowed to see the motivation and the smaller events that lined up to make it happen. The author is also careful not to make the coincidence resolve the solution outright, but give the first step towards advancing the plot.

Which brings me back to yesterday’s boiler service. The wrong engineer turning up at exactly the right time feels bizarre until we unwind that chain of events: there was existing confusion between the addresses, both households had booked the same boiler services in the same timeframe, and the engineers even wore matching Worcester Bosch sweaters.

Not one of those elements was remarkable on its own, but together, they produced a story more absurd than could be passed off as fiction.

What Are the Chances?

On 4 December 1956, an extraordinary coincidence happened. Elvis Presley, Jerry Lee Lewis, Carl Perkins and Johnny Cash all happened to drop by Sun Record Studios in Memphis, which resulted in an impromptu jam session. The engineer had the foresight to record the session, and it’s now a celebrated event among rock ‘n’ roll fans.

On Wednesday of last week, I experienced a similar such meeting. I arrived 15 minutes early for a particular class, but nobody else had arrived after a five-minute wait. I then doubted myself and thought I should perhaps be in another class on the other side of the campus. I immediately headed there.

I had to excuse myself through hundreds of other students, coming the other way, aware that time was ticking away rapidly. When I reached the entrance, I happened to meet Classmate A and explained the situation. As we made our way through the crowds, we met Classmate B by chance and brought him with us. As we approached our destination, we happened to see Classmate C, who joined our small group.

Had you written either of these situations into a novel, the reader might have some difficulty suspending their disbelief. In short, coincidences don’t work particularly well in fiction, even though they happen all the time in real life. It’s related to the broader deus ex machina, when a seemingly unsolvable problem is abruptly resolved by some unexpected intervention.

One way to help the reader maintain that disbelief is to set a few parameters. This could be as simple as dropping a few hints earlier in the story. To demonstrate this, let’s break down my classroom anecdote.

My three classmates and I knew we could only be in one of two particular classrooms, so Classmate D had gone to the second room first, since she was just as unsure as me. And although the rooms were at opposite sides of the campus, there is a main thoroughfare that most students would use to travel from one to the other. So the crowds were not a hindrance to the four of us meeting, rather they were subconsciously leading us to each other.

If I included this incident in a fictional story with that background detail worked into it – Show, don’t tell, said Elmore Leonard – it’s more likely that the reader would see the meeting as quite a reasonable coincidence. It might even be possible to deconstruct the Million Dollar Quartet in a similar fashion. For a start, the label’s owner had brought along Jerry Lee Lewis as an instrumentalist for Carl Perkins, and Johnny Cash later wrote that he had already planned to see Perkins’ recording session that day.

Identify the parameters to help the reader believe those coincidences.

[EDIT on 16 November 2026: The following links are no longer live.]

This blog has been available at http://www.gavincameron.me.uk since it began last year. But from today, if you type http://www.gavincameron.scot into your browser, it’s no coincidence you’ll also end up here.